Being transferred from one part of the country to another should not automatically be seen as punishment for a civil servant, former Head of Ghana’s Civil Service, Dr Alex Glover, has said.
He believes transfers should be treated as a normal administrative process rather than a disciplinary tool used to punish public officers accused of wrongdoing.
In an interview with broadcaster Kafui Dey, Dr Glover said the practice had become so common that whenever a civil servant was transferred, people immediately wanted to know what offence the individual had committed.
“Transferring civil servants is almost like a punishment, that you misbehave or they want to punish you, then they just throw you somewhere,” he said.
He expressed concern that certain parts of the country had acquired a reputation as places where public officers were sent as a form of punishment.
“Certain parts of the country have become like Siberia, and so if you are sent there, you are being punished,” he said, adding that changing this perception was something he was determined to address during his tenure.
Dr Glover argued that the entire country should be considered part of the area of responsibility of the Civil Service, rather than treating postings to particular regions as a penalty.
His concerns extended to the use of transfers to deal with allegations of misconduct.
He recalled instances where ministers wanted him to transfer civil servants out of their ministries following complaints against them. However, he said his approach was to insist on investigations before taking disciplinary action.
In one instance, a minister asked him to transfer an officer from the ministry. Dr Glover said he requested a written report detailing the allegations so the matter could be investigated.
He questioned the value of simply moving an accused officer to another ministry without establishing whether the allegations were true.
“If I move Mr A from Ministry A to Ministry B, you would have had relief if the accusation is correct. But the person is still under my responsibility. I still have that headache. As far as I’m concerned, you haven’t helped me in any way,” he recounted telling the minister.
He argued that transferring an officer accused of misconduct could simply move the problem elsewhere, allowing the individual to repeat the same behaviour.
Using the example of a teacher accused of a sexual offence or theft, Dr Glover questioned why such cases should be handled by transferring the teacher to another school instead of reporting the matter to the appropriate authorities.
“What is necessary is that we institute an investigation and then we determine whether the person has done wrong or not. If the person has done wrong, we punish him. We don’t leave him to go to another place and repeat the same offence,” he said.
Dr Glover maintained that disciplinary action should be based on the outcome of a proper investigation, not merely on accusations or pressure from influential individuals.
He suggested that where allegations are made, a committee should be constituted to investigate the matter and recommend appropriate action based on its findings.
“Just find, constitute a committee, investigate, and then depending on the report, you take action,” he said.