Imagine walking through the streets and coming across someone selling your music, only for you to realize that you are not earning a pesewa from the transaction.
For Ghanaian musician Nana Fynn, this was not a hypothetical situation. He says he once encountered a street vendor in Kumasi who attempted to sell him copies of his own music.
The Highlife musician recounted the experience during an interview with Kafui Dey, using the incident to highlight the challenges of music piracy and the exploitation of artistes within the music business.
Nana Fynn said the vendor was so confident about the copies he was selling that he insisted they were authentic.
The musician admitted that he was initially prepared to buy one of the copies to establish what was happening.
“I was ready to buy as proof for myself,” he recalled.
However, the seller eventually ran away, leaving Nana Fynn disappointed by the encounter.
“I was sad,” he said.
For the musician, the painful part was not simply seeing someone selling his music. It was watching his creative work being commercialised without him receiving anything from the transaction.
“Because that’s your work. That’s my life, man,” he told Kafui Dey.
He added: “The life is being sold in the street like that and you are not earning anything.”
But Nana Fynn’s concerns about exploitation in the music industry go beyond street piracy.
He also recounted what he described as a troubling practice in music promotion, where artistes allegedly pay DJs not only to play their songs but also to stop playing the music of competing musicians.
Using an illustrative example, he explained how two artistes releasing songs in the same genre could approach a producer or DJ with money to promote their respective records.
However, if one song began gaining more attention, the competing artiste could allegedly offer the DJ more money to stop playing it for a specified period.
Nana Fynn illustrated the practice with an example involving one artiste who had paid GH¢200 to have a song played, while another offered GH¢500 to have that song taken off the DJ’s playlist for two months, with the possibility of an additional payment.
The musician questioned why both artistes could not be given an opportunity to have their songs played.
“Why can’t he play both people’s music? Why do they have to play?” he asked.
He said the practice had seriously affected the industry.
“It disturbed our industry big time,” he stated.
According to Nana Fynn, the alleged practice was not limited to DJs. He claimed that some producers, distributors, musicians and management teams were also involved.
His allegations extended to the gospel music sector, which he said was not exempt.
“Gospel musicians were in it. Gospel producers were in it,” he revealed.
Describing what he considered the motivation behind the practice, Nana Fynn said: “Greed is the name of the game. Very sad.”
He believes the industry should encourage healthy competition instead of creating an environment where musicians attempt to block one another’s progress.
“The universe is big enough for everybody,” he said.
Explaining his philosophy, he added: “There’s enough space in the sky for every star to shine.”
THE DISTRIBUTOR BETRAYAL
Nana Fynn also revisited the challenges musicians faced during the cassette and CD era, alleging that some distributors entrusted with selling artistes’ music would reproduce additional copies without their knowledge or permission.
He explained that musicians would approach distributors in towns such as Kumasi and Takoradi, supply them with copies of their albums and announce that the distributors were the official points of sale.
In his example, an artiste could supply a distributor with 1,000 cassettes. But when the music became popular and demand increased, the distributor would allegedly produce additional copies for sale.
The musician said the artiste would not receive any money from those extra sales.
When Kafui Dey described the situation as effectively stabbing the artiste in the back, Nana Fynn agreed.
He explained that the distributor could use the popularity of an artiste’s music to push unauthorised copies while benefiting financially from the arrangement.
“So when he sells 10 of yours, he will sell 100 of his,” Nana Fynn said.
The situation, he explained, could force musicians to terminate their relationships with distributors, often without concrete evidence to support their suspicions.
“You don’t have any proof. So you just have to change the distributor. That’s it,” he said.
But by the time an artiste discovers what is happening, valuable promotional time may already have been lost.
Nana Fynn explained that such a situation could emerge six or seven months into an album promotion campaign, forcing the musician to start promoting another song to revive interest in the album.
STREAMING HAS NOT SOLVED EVERYTHING
The musician also questioned whether the shift from physical music sales to digital streaming has necessarily improved the financial position of artistes.
Asked whether the digital transformation had worked to their advantage, he responded:
“No. As far as I’m concerned, it’s not to anybody’s advantage, but it’s technology.”
He argued that the companies manufacturing the devices used to consume music and the streaming platforms were among those benefiting significantly from the digital music economy.
“Technology doesn’t really think about you, man. It’s technology,” he said.
He added that companies manufacturing tablets and earphones, as well as streaming platforms such as Spotify, were making money from the changing music landscape.
“They are the guys. They are the ones,” he said.
Nana Fynn expressed support for the renewed interest in physical music formats such as CDs and vinyl, arguing that they could allow musicians to retain more control over their earnings.
“That’s why CDs must come back. I’m happy it’s coming back,” he said, adding that vinyl releases could also help artistes keep more of the money generated from their music.